When Schumer Lost the Ability to Lead.

A loss of courage and imagination over the past two years have disqualified Chuck Schumer from any claim to Senate leadership.

Steve Villano

38 minutes ago

Time, courage & imagination have passed Chuck Schumer by.

(Photo by Haiyun Jiang for the New York Times, 3/14/25).

Nine months before Donald Trump was re-elected President, then-Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, was—believe it or not— a profile in courage.

While Joe Biden was still President, and slavishly shipping “Bunker Buster” bombs to Israel, Schumer stood in the well of the U.S. Senate in mid-March, 2024, and directly challenged Israel’s recklessly disproportionate slaughter of tens of thousand of Palestinian children and women in Gaza, and the lawless reign of terror of Israeli Prime Minister, Bibi Netanyahu, beholden to Israel’s xenophobic Extreme Right Wing.

Schumer, the highest ranking elected Jewish public official in American history, knew what he was risking. His hold on Senate leadership was tenuous, if AIPAC—the Right Wing political action committee doing Bibi’s bidding in US Elections—shifted their considerable financial support behind Republican Senate candidates instead of Democrats. Still, he fearlessly confronted the bully Bibi, and the Extremist Kahanist cabal controlling Israel, and the fawning fealty of the Biden/Harris Administration.

Schumer, never a spellbinding speaker, rose to the occasion, and was shockingly eloquent:

“I speak for myself, but I also speak for so many mainstream Jewish Americans — a silent majority — whose nuanced views on the matter have never been well represented in this country’s discussions about the war in Gaza….

“I speak as a member of a community of Jewish Americans that I know very well. They are my family, my friends. Many of them are my constituents, many of them are Democrats and many are deeply concerned about the pursuit of justice, both in New York and around the globe. From the Talmud — Tikkun Olam, the call to “repair the world” — has driven Jews around the globe to do what is right….

Schumer detailed the horrific crimes committed by Hamas on October 7, 2023—less then 6 months before he spoke out—when 1200 Israelis and others were murdered, some 200 innocent hostage were forcibly kidnapping, and the disproportionate response of the Israeli Government—in direct contravention of the IDF’s own Ethical Code of Conduct in War—resulted in the indiscriminate bombing and slaughter of tens of thousands of innocent Palestinian children and women.

“The only real and sustainable solution to this decades-old conflict is a negotiated two-state solution — a demilitarized Palestinian state living side-by-side with Israel in equal measures of peace, security, prosperity, dignity and mutual recognition,” Schumer said from the Senate floor…I also believe Prime Minister Netanyahu has lost his way by allowing his political survival to take precedence over the best interests of Israel.

Schumer was surgical in his slicing up of Netanyahu’s assault on the highly regarded Israeli Judiciary, calling it a “weakening of Israel’s political and moral fabric, “ pointing out Bibi’s contemptuous disregard for the Rule of Law, and his embracing a lawless, extremist fringe of Israeli society—some of whom had been convicted of acts of terror, and tied to groups responsible for the assassination of former Prime Minister Yitzak Rabin– which did not recognize the legitimacy of the Judiciary, or any limits to the use of violence.

“Prime Minister Netanyahu has put himself in coalition with far-right extremists like Ministers Smotrich and Ben Gvir, and as a result, he has been too willing to tolerate the civilian toll in Gaza…As a lifelong supporter of Israel, it has become clear to me:

The Netanyahu coalition no longer fits the needs of Israel… The world has changed — radically — and the Israeli people are being stifled right now by a governing vision that is stuck in the past”

Schumer’s courageous comments stunned the Biden White House, itself caught up in playing a duplicitous game, condemning Israel’s slaughter of innocent civilians and deprivation of humanitarian aid to Gaza residents, and continuing to supply Israel with the huge, 2,000 pound American bombs that were causing massive destruction and loss of human life in Gaza. It was a morally indefensible position.

American Jews, like myself and my own Rabbi, were proud that at last a major Jewish leader in this country was finally willing to confront the anti-democratic, anti-Jewish, Netanyahu government, which had wiped out Israel’s original governing laws, and the fundamental tenets of Judaism that revolve around a reverence for humanity.

A New York Times story of March 19, 2024, entitled “Part of my Core: How Schumer Decided to Speak Out Against Netanyahu,” noted that Schumer too, was influenced by what his Rabbi was saying.

Rabbi Rachel Timoner, from Schumer’s Reform Synagogue in Brooklyn, who had spoken movingly about the excruciating moral questions raised by this war in Gaza, told Schumer that the Far Right Extremists in Netanyahu’s government were: “endangering all of us because their agenda is about dehumanizing Palestinians, and it’s undermining Israel’s democracy and dearest values.”

Timoner told the New York Times, that she and Senator Schumer:

“share the belief that Israel has a right to defend itself against Hamas but talked about the desperate need to bring the hostages home and end the humanitarian crisis in Gaza through an agreement… even if we would only care about Israel’s safety and security, this war was actually harming Israel on the world stage and its relationship with the United States.”

Rabbi Timoner went on to tell The Times, what she thought of Schumer’s speech calling for new elections in Israel:

“This was him trying to discern the moral path and trying to step up in a way he knew was risky for him, to do something that he felt deeply was right.”

That delicate balancing act blew up in Schumer’s face three months later when Netanyahu came to address a Joint Session of Congress, with Schumer’s blessing. Bibi’s predictable blustering was bulging with calls for more blatant Israeli nationalism and the indiscriminate killing of non-combatant Palestinians, and accolades to Donald Trump, who was locked in a close Presidential campaign with Joe Biden, and later, Kamala Harris.

The following year almost to the day, after Trump’s re-election to the Presidency, Schumer lost his courage and his ability to lead. He dissolved into the shadow of his own cowardice, and his own failure to recognize that time and circumstances had made his old style of politics obsolete. Schumer had become, as he accused Bibi of being one year earlier, “stuck in the past.”

Two months into the new, more extremist Second Trump Administration, and locked in a life and death struggle for the survival of humanitarian domestic programs nurtured since LBJ’s “Great Society” became part of the fabric of American life, Schumer lost his courage.

In what may well have been the worst and most damaging speech of his long public career in the Senate, Schumer failed to seize the moment and articulate the extraordinary damage being done to ordinary Americans every single day by Donald Trump, Elon Musk, Stephen Miller, Russell Voight and the anti-human rights, anti-Semitic screeds contained in Pogrom 2025, the call for a Christian, non-Jewish nation written by Voight and other Christian Nationalists hell-bent on conducting a jihad against anyone “different” from their definition of who belonged in “Christian America.”

A mere year earlier, Schumer had fearlessly confronted Bibi and his phalanx of fascist Right Wing extremists, threatening Israel’s very existence as a Democracy. Yet, when it came time to muster the same kind of courage at a crucial moment in the fight for democracy in his own country—and beat back the forces of extremism, nihilism and techno-terror tearing fundamental US government services away from veterans, the elderly, children and those most in need, Schumer slithered under a cloak of cowardice.

Fearing an imagined “far worse” outcome for the country if he stood strong against the Republican’s Continuing Resolution (CR) designed to cripple social programs for most Americans, Schumer slinked off, squandering the powerful card of resistance he held. The Senior Senator from New York, whimpered away into the night, without as much as a whisper of a fight. It was hard to imagine how much worse things could get than the four-horrific horsemen of Trump/Musk/Voight/Miller had already made them for millions of Americans. But Schumer suffered from both a lack of will—and of a bold imagination—to fight the forces of fascism tightening the screws on working people.

Instead of caving, Schumer could have held the Senate Floor for many hours, allowing Democratic leaders and veterans like Senator Mark Kelly, Tammy Duckworth and Ruben Gallego to filibuster against the life-threatening impact the Trump/Musk/Voight/Miller attack upon the VA, for example, has had on Veterans Services, and how it was Veterans and people of color who were suffering the greatest personal damage and loss of income from the wholesale elimination of tens of thousands of their jobs. He could have brought thousands of individual stories to the floor of the Senate—and into the living rooms of millions of Americans—to make his point and win the fight for the soul of the nation.

Holding the Senate floor open for hours would have enabled Senators to express the outrage of their constituents from across the country, dominated media coverage for as long as they kept the debate burning, inundated social media, TV and all media with scorched earth attacks on how the GOP was fire-bombing all public human services, the way White Supremacists set Black Wall Street ablaze in Tulsa, Oklahoma, in 1921.

A simple delay of a vote by Schumer, would have allowed time for citizen advocacy groups like Indivisible, Vote Vets, the ACLU, Democracy FORWARD, the SCLC, the NAACP’s Legal Defense Fund and others to challenge and condemn Elon Musk’s illegal mass firings and his theft of the private, proprietary data of hundreds of millions of Americans.

And, if Schumer showed some guts and signaled he was ready to fight into the night, instead of hiding in his own shadow, public employee unions whose members are reeling from a frontal attack on the US Government by a band of felons, would have had the time to organize by the tens of thousands in DC and in communities and states across the country, where most publicemployees labor to improve the lives of their neighbors.

It was then—long before Maryland’s Democratic Senator Chris Van Hallen stepped forward to challenge his stale, lazy leadership—that Chuck Schumer relinquished his leadership position in the US Senate. He failed miserably to make even the faintest effort to galvanize the forces of common sense and humanity against the CR—or Catastrophic Resolution. Schumer needed then, more than ever, to remember what his Rabbi said about him during his finest hour, one year earlier, when he stood up to AIPAC and Bibi Netanyahu and extreme Right Wing forces in Israel:

“This was him trying to discern the moral path and trying to step up in a way he knew was risky for him, to do something that he felt deeply was right.”

That’s when we needed unshakeable moral courage from Schumer—staring into the terrorist teeth of Trump and the extreme Right Wing forces in our own country, and the chainsaw they used to chop-up life and death public services for millions of us, and for children worldwide.

Instead, at that crucial moment in time, Chuck Schumer gave us only cautious cowardice, tempered by his fear of losing political power, causing him to slip behind his own shadows in the night.

That’s the very moment Schumer showed us that his days as a political leader were over, and that his own political vision was stuck in the rear-view mirror.

Now, that the Democratic Party has passed him by, and a new team of Democratic Senators have redefined confidence, courage and moral leaderhip, it’s time for Chuck Schumer to gracefully pass the torch of leadership—a torch he has proven himself to be incapable of carrying into the future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *